Hobby Lobby Win At Supreme Court Could Lead To More Anti-Gay Laws

Posted on 03 March 2014 by Gay/Lesbian News

Arizona’s attempt to let businesses refuse to serve LGBT people on religious grounds sparked significantly more bipartisan outrage than Republicans’ similar efforts to allow companies to refuse to cover birth control. But the two ideas are really a package deal, women’s groups are warning.

“What you’re seeing in both cases are corporations asserting the right to break the law in the name of religion, even if it results in harm and discrimination for third parties,” said Emily Martin, vice president and general counsel for the National Women’s Law Center. “What’s been really heartening with the Arizona case is the recognition that that’s a radical idea.”

The Arizona bill, which Gov. Jan Brewer (R) vetoed following a nationwide backlash from both sides of the aisle, would have allowed businesses like florists and caterers to deny service to gay people on religious grounds. A number of prominent Republicans, including Arizona Sen. John McCain and former GOP presidential nominee Mitt Romney, strongly opposed the bill, despite having previously supported legislation to allow for-profit companies to refuse to cover birth control on religious grounds.

The Supreme Court will hear oral argument later this month in Sebelius v. Hobby Lobby Stores Inc. on the question of whether for-profit corporations have a right to free exercise of religion that would permit them to deny birth control coverage despite the Affordable Care Act provision requiring most employers to cover contraception in their health plans. If Hobby Lobby wins, it could open the door to more anti-gay laws and other kinds of legalized discrimination under the guise of “religious freedom,” women’s health groups argue.

“All of these attacks are cut from the same dangerous cloth, and they would roll back the clock on the balance our nation has struck to respect religious beliefs while protecting the rights and liberties of all,” Planned Parenthood said in a joint statement with nearly 50 LGBT and human rights groups on Monday. “LGBT people could be turned away at hotels and restaurants, women could be denied access to birth control, people with HIV or AIDS could be denied health care, single mothers could be denied bank loans, and children could be prevented from getting immunizations.”

Some conservative groups are shying away from the comparison. A spokesperson for the Becket Fund for Religious Liberty, the public interest law firm representing Hobby Lobby, told HuffPost that the fund would not comment at all on the Arizona bill because it’s a “completely different issue.”

Other conservative groups have jumped to the defense of the Arizona bill while acknowledging its connection to the birth control argument.

“Indeed, the Arizona law would protect groups like Hobby Lobby from a state-level HHS mandate coercing them to provide insurance coverage that violated their religious convictions,” wrote Ryan T. Anderson of the Heritage Foundation. “The crucial question here is not whether you yourself would or wouldn’t pay for abortion-inducing drugs and contraception, but whether government should force the Little Sisters of the Poor to do so.”

The case of the Little Sisters of the Poor is different, however, because the nuns already qualify for Obamacare’s accommodation, which allows religious nonprofits to opt out of directly paying for birth control by asking a third-party insurance company to pay for it. The nuns are objecting to the act of directing someone else to cover birth control for their employees.

Martin said she thinks the link between denying birth control coverage and denying services to LGBT people could tip the scales against Hobby Lobby’s argument — if not at the Supreme Court level, then at least in the realm of public opinion.

“It’s always hard to tell how current events play into a justice’s perception, but the connections being so visibly drawn will only help in making clear that the rights that are being asserted in the Hobby Lobby case have very broad and troubling implications,” she said.

Powered by WPeMatico

Share

Comments are closed.

Advertise Here

Photos from our Flickr stream

See all photos

Advertise Here

Ad Squares Widget

Ad Square Ad Square

Ad Squares Widget

Ad Square Ad Square
Share
  • Human rights leaders speak out for LGBT equality
    YouTube Video
    Human rights leaders speak out for LGBT equality
    UN Human Rights Chief Navi Pillay, Archbishop Emeritus Desmond Tutu and South Africa's Justice Edwin Cameron speak out for the human rights of lesbian, gay, ...
  • Pinoys join the march for LGBT rights in US, UK
    YouTube Video
    Pinoys join the march for LGBT rights in US, UK
    A thousand people marched in various parts of the world to promote the equal rights of lesbian, gay, bisexual and transgender (LGBT). Filipinos joined in the...
  • LGBT: The New Civil Rights
    YouTube Video
    LGBT: The New Civil Rights
    Today's civil rights issues are equality and fair treatment for the LGBT -- lesbian, gay, bi-sexual, transgender, community. The CMC forum panel on Feb. 5, m...
  • Deputy Assistant Secretary Remarks on Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual, and Transgender (LGBT) Pride
    YouTube Video
    Deputy Assistant Secretary Remarks on Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual, and Transgender (LGBT) Pride
    Deputy Assistant Secretary of State for Democracy, Human Rights and Labor Daniel B. Baer delivers remarks on Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual, and Transgender (LGBT) P...
  • President Obama's message to the National Conference on LGBT Equality: Creating Change
    YouTube Video
    President Obama's message to the National Conference on LGBT Equality: Creating Change
    President Barack Obama issued a video statement airing today before 3000 lesbian, gay, bisexual and transgender (LGBT) rights advocates assembled for the Na...
  • Google Search Gay, Lesbian, BiSexual, TransGender and LGBT 2013
    YouTube Video
    Google Search Gay, Lesbian, BiSexual, TransGender and LGBT 2013
    http://bit.ly/11oRxbA | In celebration of equal rights, the proudly gay-friendly search giant has hidden a fabulous easter egg for users who search "gay." Th...
  • Highlights from First-Ever Ministerial Meeting on LGBT Rights
    YouTube Video
    Highlights from First-Ever Ministerial Meeting on LGBT Rights
    On 26 September 2013, leaders from the UN's core group of countries working to end violence and discrimination against lesbian, gay, bisexual and transgender...
  • LiveAtState: Human Rights of Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual, and Transgender People
    YouTube Video
    LiveAtState: Human Rights of Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual, and Transgender People
    U.S. Deputy Assistant Secretary, Bureau of Democracy, Human Rights, and Labor Daniel Baer participates in a conversations on human rights of lesbian, gay, bi...
  • Violation of human rights of LGBT people around the world: a UN message
    YouTube Video
    Violation of human rights of LGBT people around the world: a UN message
    The United Nations, in collaboration with the Municipality of Sao Paulo, launches on Monday 28 April the "Free and Equal" campaign. Having into consideration...
  • Celina Jaitley Makes Her Singing Debut In Video Promotes Gay Rights
    YouTube Video
    Celina Jaitley Makes Her Singing Debut In Video Promotes Gay Rights
    Bollywood actress and rights activist Celina Jaitley has lent her voice to United Nations' music video to promote LGBT (lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender) ...

RELATED SITES